Author: Elisabeth Gifford
Corvus RRP $29.99
Review: Monique Mulligan

Secrets of the Sea HouseMulti-generational stories about long-buried secrets and mysteries have always appealed to me; when I saw some friends recommend Secrets of the Sea House I knew I had to bump this one up the pile. I was rewarded with a haunting and satisfying read that more than lived up to the expectations other readers had generated.

When Ruth and Michael buy the Sea House, a grand but dilapidated old building on the isolated Hebridean island of Harris, they have big plans. A bed and breakfast is one, but mostly, they want to turn the house into a home for their hoped-for family. During the renovation, a shocking discovery is made. Buried beneath the floors are the tiny bones of a baby, its legs fused together, like a mermaid. Ruth can’t stop thinking about the bones and resolves to get to the bottom of the mystery. Who buried the bones? And why? As she asks questions, she comes across the writings of Reverend Alexander Ferguson, who in 1860 took up the parish on the island and lived in the Sea House. Reading his writing gives Ruth a perspective on island life at the time, and leads to more questions, not only about the buried baby, but her own past.

As Ruth discovers, life on the island in the 1860s was harsh and unforgiving, with the climate and terrain only partly to blame. A ruthless and greedy landowner would stop at nothing to build his ’empire’, while his tenants lived in make-shift houses, barely surviving and forever in his debt. Those who could not pay his unfair debts were sent away on ships, either to another island, and some as far as Canada. I could understand and identify the Reverend’s frustration and Ruth’s horror, for I felt it too as I read. Gifford painted a depressing scene with descriptions at the same time vivid and bleak. Her writing is emotive but considered – the bleakness is not overwhelming, as it could well have been, and instead the language and description delivers a haunting sense of place. The legend of the Selkie (seal-people) was cleverly woven into the story, adding depth and interest.

Infused in the story are themes of identity and belonging, of love and loss, and hope and despair. As Ruth tries to discover the identity of the ‘mermaid’ child she is led towards self-discovery and healing. Who was her father? What are her roots? Somehow, Ruth’s identity is tied up with the myths of the Selkie people, as was Alexander’s, and Gifford ties all the threads together well. I particularly enjoyed Alexander’s and his housemaid Moira’s stories – they were riveting. I liked the depth that their different perspectives added to the reader’s understanding – more than there would have been with just Alexander’s writing to go by. Alexander was somewhat removed from the troubles the islanders had, whereas Moira had been displaced and watched her extended family be displaced once more, with tragic results.

For me, it’s hard to go wrong with a story like this – a big house holding secrets, a contemporary protagonist committed to uncovering the secrets (and learning about herself along the way, and a historical narrative that beguiles the reader with its intricacies. If you like gothic-style stories like this, or you’re a fan of writers like Kate Morton, don’t miss Secrets of the Sea House. I loved it. 

Available from good bookstores and Allen & Unwin. This copy was courtesy of Allen & Unwin.

Bookish treat: Hot chips. Why? Sea, fish, chips … see where my reasoning is going?



Monique Mulligan

Monique Mulligan

0 Responses

  1. I’m a bit embarrassed by my failure to comment because, I read a fair few Blogs which give book reviews, but yours is genuinely outstanding. The reviews are so well written and reflective, that I have a significant faith in your impression. I read your reviews just for the pleasure of reading them. I love to read myself, as well as write, but life has been a bit hectic for a while and I’ve not had the space to read books much. When I get that moment, your site is one of the first places I will come to for inspiration

    1. Well, you just put a big smile on my face. It’s been one of those days so this was lovely to read. Thank you so much for that feedback. I will treasure it.

Related Posts

Your basket is currently empty.

Return to shop